Romanelli's Pizza & Italian Eatery

Romanelli's Pizza & Italian Eatery, nestled in Madison, NJ, is a charming pizzeria that captures the essence of classic Italian dining. Customers rave about the delicious offerings, from perfectly cooked spinach and cheese pizzas, noted for their flavorful garlic infusion, to a fan-favorite penne vodka that kids can't get enough of. The square grandma-style pizza is a local highlight, acclaimed for its well-baked, thin crust that evokes the taste of authentic New York pizza.

The atmosphere is warmly reminiscent of old-school Jersey eateries, contributing to a delightful dining experience. However, consistency seems to be a factor; while many diners praise the quality and service—citing it as the best pizza in town—some critiques mention room for improvement in pasta preparation. Nonetheless, the community appreciation shines through, especially with Romanelli's proactive involvement in local fundraisers.

With its fair pricing and commitment to quality, Romanelli's stands out as a hidden gem in Madison, ideal for both a casual meal and special occasions. As avid food lovers continue to explore the menu, it’s a place that invites you to indulge in tasty Italian fare while enjoying the comforting ambiance akin to a neighborhood gathering spot.